My First Cheesecake (Certainly Not Award Winning, But Noteworthy Nonetheless)

August 1, 2012

My First Cheesecake - Sweet and Savoring [photo by Andy Milford]

Today. Today was the day of our housewarming party. I had made the blondies, and prepared the pitcher of water with fresh lemon and basil for the guests who didn’t drink, and assembled all of the ingredients for my homemade pesto (I think that merits its own post entirely) on the countertop.

Of course, there was one thing missing. Here it was August, and my husband, Andy, had celebrated his birthday in January.  I kept promising that I was going to make him a cake, and then it was the summer, and so I said it would be a cake in honor of his half birthday.  Naturally, July was the busiest month of our entire (nine month) marriage.  And so, it came to be that I was making a birthday cheesecake, my very first mind you, on the day of our housewarming party.

I scoured my bookmarked food sites to see if I could find a recipe that would be relatively easy for this cheesecake virgin, while simultaneously peppering my sister, Sue, with questions (since, as far as I can tell, she has made 100 or more varieties of every cake, bar, cookie and pie known to man).  Since it was, as usual, a hot and humid day and I had had less-than-desirable results with my new-old oven, I decided on a no-bake variety: just cream cheese, lemon juice, sugar, vanilla extract, heavy cream, and a bit of cinnamon (my favorite spice! It makes everything taste sweeter!).

My First Cheesecake - Sweet and Savoring

We both knew I was a bit out of luck in the appliances department.  Compared to Sue, I have a bit of a minimalist kitchen, which is to say that I do not own an electric mixer (or an immersion blender. Or an egg beater. Or a food processor! What? And here I am, blogging about food!) So it’s possible that I complained while trying to soften two sticks of hard cream cheese with just a wooden spoon and my out-of-shape arm muscles, but I pushed through with thoughts of the finished product (plus some forced optimism).

My First Cheesecake - Sweet and Savoring

Next, I decided to stray from the recipe slightly by adding some fresh strawberry juice, a task which then morphed into just smushing up strawberries and mixing them in.  Why not throw in a little something extra?

My First Cheesecake - Sweet and Savoring

Tell me this doesn’t look like a blobby strawberry-man. Or maybe this is like an ink blot test. What do you see?

And then, it was time to transfer the batter into the pie pan:

My First Cheesecake - Sweet and Savoring

The clock was ticking, and I knew the cheesecake needed a few hours in the refrigerator in order to properly set, so I put on the finishing touches and hoped for the best.

My First Cheesecake - Sweet and Savoring

I presented my masterpiece to Andy during the party, well into the evening. Unfortunately there are no shots of individual slices, because…well, they just weren’t very photogenic.  Somehow there wasn’t much firmness to the whole thing, but everyone who ate it was full of praise, so either our friends are too nice, or I made my first halfway decent (mushy) cheesecake!

My First Cheesecake - Sweet and Savoring [photo by Andy Milford]

Ta da! I managed not to overdo it when I arranged the strawberries.


The recipe I used was adapted from here. Next time, I’ll definitely attempt a genuine, baked cheesecake.

The only real stumbling block is fear of failure. In cooking you’ve got to have a ‘What the hell?’ attitude.  -Julia Child

You Might Also Like

  • Sue August 21, 2012 at 9:10 am

    That cheesecake was really tasty. And don’t take it to heart that it didn’t set very well…it was pretty humid that day.

    • Christy August 21, 2012 at 9:16 am

      Oh, how loyal you are 🙂 Yep, actually I *should* think of the humidity- remember the blondies? (poor things)

      And I just had the brilliant idea to feature you in a post all your own! You baking…something. Got any plans on the horizon?

  • Joe August 21, 2012 at 10:50 pm

    Okay, I’ll be honest, I wasn’t expecting much from this (I’m not exactly what you’d call an avid blog reader, you know what I mean?), but that was pretty interesting to read. Your writing style is unique, the subject matter is something I find interesting but don’t really do much with myself, and your pictures were (as they always are) AWESOME. I approve of this blog.

    • Christy August 21, 2012 at 10:57 pm

      Oh, Joe you just made my night! Thank you for your sweet words! I think this was my favorite comment yet. Best Nephew Ever Award coming your way 🙂

    %d bloggers like this: